Parenting (individually and institutionally) is hard, and it requires
establishing guidelines and working from some kind of base paradigm. I
see the helicopter version, fundamentally, as based upon a paradigm of
fear -which, again, is not always a bad or inaccurate thing. It’s when
any approach (helicoptering or hands-off) is taken to the extreme that
the real issues arise. All other non-extreme approaches are
combinations of the two opposite poles, and finding the non-extreme
paradigm that works at the individual and organizational level is
difficult, especially when members of the group don’t agree on what the
proper balance is – and even more so when the group includes members who
land everywhere on the spectrum from one extreme to the other.
I have a hard enough time figuring out a good balance for myself,
much less for my children – and much, much less as the organizational
numbers grow.
The LDS Church certainly has elements of helicoptering in it – and
some of them are closer to the extreme than to the dead center. I would
love to see those things moderated toward the center, but that reflects
my paradigm and not necessarily those of other members. There are
other areas where I love the freedom I have in the Church, even when
those areas drive some members nuts who want more security and peace of
mind.
As a good friend said once about charges of cult-like behavior, I try
to recognize institutional examples of unhealthy helicoptering and ask:
“Lord, is it I?”
All too often, it is.
3 comments:
Is there actually any evidence that helicopter parenting is unhealthy?
Not in moderation, Matt - and I tried to address that in the post, but it could have been more explicit. It's when it moves toward the extreme that the serious issues begin to arise.
For me the issue with helicopter parenting is that of free agency-whilst I intend to offer my children every opportunity to choose that which I feel is right, it is essential to allow them to make the choice. Reality is that I'm not always going to be there.
I'm also not arrogant enough to believe that I'm right about everything-it's been a great lesson to me to realise that God will do his own work with my children. I endeavour to teach my children correct principles, and encourage them to govern them selves.
Post a Comment