I have some communal responsibility for the messages I send through the actions I choose.
I have no argument whatsoever with that principle.
I alone am responsible, ultimately, for what I think and how I act - no matter what messages are being sent by others.
I have no argument whatsoever with that principle.
"Modesty" is a concept that embraces both of the principles above -
an attempt to create a reasonable "middle ground" that doesn't emphasize the communal OR the individual above the other. Modesty is not about being "true" or "right"; it's about being "moderate", "reasonable" and "charitable".
Once
moderation, reason and charity leave the equation, modesty no longer exists - and
modesty can be very different things in very different cultures. It's
not the exact line that is drawn that is important; it's if that middle ground line
works for reasonable men and women within their community.
Overall,
I have little passionate argument with the general idea of how modesty
of dress is approached within the official standards of the LDS Church - meaning
that
I accept as a reasonable balance attire that covers garments for
general, non-specific, public appearance by church members as the standard for adults.
That leaves exceptions for differing activities where deviations from
that norm make sense, while it also allows for those who want more
restrictive guidelines for themselves to be able to dress as
conservatively as they want.
Where my passionate argument
exists is when the general, non-specific, church member, public appearance norm is
applied to non-adults, non-LDS members and to situations outside that
norm - and when the more strict norm becomes a
de facto
norm by dint of majority insistence.
I also object to how it is almost
exclusively women who bear the brunt of the responsibility - when male
communal input outweighs communal female input, and women become walking
pornography but men never hear about their effect on and responsibility
toward women. I also object when women who actually are dressed
"modestly" are seen as walking pornography, since that situation is a
problem with the men who see them in ways they need not be seen.
For example, "more modest" really is being "immodest" - being out-of-balance. That's a great example of what I mean when I say that we collectively don't understand what modesty really means.
We
are so steeped in a Victorian view of sex that we collectively see lots
of things as wrong and pornographic that are only wrong and
pornographic because we make them so.
Nudity is not the same as
pornography - but we are close to the point where we are collectively
equating the two. That, to me, is the heart of the issue - and
decoupling the two is the most important, effective "first step" I know.